StoreFrontCrashExpert.com
Find me socially:
  • Home
  • About Rob
  • Storefront Crash Statistics
    • Our Research
    • Statistics By Age
    • Statistics By Cause
    • Statistics By Site Type
  • Storefront Safety Council
  • Resources
    • Articles, Media & News Reports
    • US DOT Reports
    • Websites
    • Best Practices for Prevention
    • Legislation and Safety Standards
    • Education & Presentations
  • Crash & Grab/ Ram Raids
  • The Storefront Blog
  • Contact

UPDATE -- My Inspection of Farrell's Ice Cream in Buena Park, Four Days After Fatal Pedal Error Accident.

4/29/2014

1 Comment

 
Today I had the chance to go to the Farrell's Ice Cream restaurant in Buena Park California, scene of a fatal accident which I have posted about previously.  My trip was prompted by comments from Farrel's CEO Michael Fleming, which were reported in the Orange County Register.  These remarks seemed misleading and self serving, and I wanted to go and see the situation for myself.

To see the Register's coverage and see the context of Mr. Fleming's remarks, please click HERE.

What caught my attention in the remarks was
the idea that customers were unprotected because of some code requirement for ADA compliant parking.  The entire frontage of the restaurant is taken up by five parking spaces, of which four are marked ADA spaces which point directly at the building entrance and seating areas.  Here is a photo taken some time before the accident last Friday night showing the layout -- Ms. Malin was struck and killed at the bench on the far right.

Picture
As you can see, all four spaces are pointed directly at the entrance or the outdoor bench seating and waiting area.  The spaces appear to be marked and striped and signed in conformance with California ADA regulations.  There is a wheel stop in front of each of the four signposts.  You can see the decorative fence in the background of the three spaces to the right of the entrance.

The Register attributes the following remarks to Mr. Fleming:


"Fleming said a new law requires that handicapped parking spaces, located directly in front of the restaurant’s front door, be level with the building. During construction, Fleming said, a curb in front of the parking spaces was removed to comply with the law. He believes that, had the curb been there, it may have slowed the car that killed Malin. He also said he’ll be speaking with the city to see what can be done to improve safety at the restaurant."

I have two objections regarding these remarks.

First, they are inaccurate.  I checked with Mr. David Vogel of Parking Design Group about these claims, and his reply was clear:  "
Accessible spaces are not required to be level with the front door.  The unloading zones of the accessible spaces need to lead to an accessible path of travel which may include a curb ramp (max. slope of 8.33% with max. 2% cross slope).  This curb ramp cannot be within the accessible space unloading zone but can be located along the accessible path of travel with detectable warning strips.  Curb ramps and detectable warning strips are covered in the Californian Building Code (CBC) Sections 11B406-2 and 11B705."

Second, if Mr. Fleming was concerned about unprotected customers, he should have put crash-resistant bollards or barriers in place to protect them instead of the ineffective wheel stop and flimsy railing that were installed.  Nothing prevented the installation of such barriers in front of the parking spaces to protect waiting customers.  I will say it again;  no ADA requirement, no building code, no architectural guideline of any kind prevented Farrell's, the parking lot designers, the building architects, or Mr. Fleming, from making sure that there was an effective barrier in place to prevent an accident exactly like this one from happening.


How do I know this?  Look again at the photo above.  Look at the entrance
of the restaurant on the left side of the photo.  No flimsy little fence there -- the entrance is protected by two sturdy six inch diameter steel bollards filled with concrete.  This clearly marked and ADA compliant accessible space and unloading zone has two steel bollards in front of them, and yet are in full compliance with the "new law" that Mr. Fleming indicated as a contributing factor in the accidental death of Marisa Malin and injuries to six others.

Here is a close-up shot of the two bollards which I took this afternoon during my site visit:

Picture
So Farrell's was concerned enough about safety to install bollards at the entrance, but not concerned enough about safety to install them in front of the other ADA spaces which pointed directly at waiting customers outside the restaurant.  Why the entrance and not the outdoor seating area?  I am sure that every litigator in Southern California would like to ask Mr. Fleming that question in a deposition.  What could be the cost difference between the decorative railings installed in the space between the pillars versus the cost of two bollards installed in the space between the pillars?  I would estimate the price difference at less than $1000.  However you put a price on one dead and six injured, I have to believe that $1000 will not begin to cover the tab in anyone's calculation.

One final point:  Mr. Fleming made it very clear that he has heard about storefront crashes such as this accident, and was aware of accidents such as this one happening frequently.  Again, quoting from the Register coverage: 

“This is one of those tragedies I’ve read about over and over again,” Fleming said. “And this time I lived it. It was horrific.”   He said that all Farrell’s locations are flying flags at half-staff in memory of Malin.

I submit two things; 

First, if you feel the need to protect your entrance with steel bollards because of the hazard of a vehicle incursion accident, why would you NOT protect the customer waiting area and benches exposed to exactly the same hazard? 

Second, if you have read about these types of accidents happening over and over again, why would you NOT
take basic steps to prevent a needless death at your new restaurant?

This accident will now fade from the news and results of
investigations will be released.  I expect that soon the lawsuits will start to be filed.  The case will eventually wind through the courts and liability will be determined and injury claims paid out.  It is so sad -- sad for the Malin family, sad for the families of those injured, sad for the driver and his family, and especially sad because this event was entirely preventable and predictable. 

The restaurant industry is on notice:  pedal error accidents occur every day.  Join the Storefront Safety Council, take a stand for safety, and protect your customers and employees against the known and frequent hazard of vehicle incursion accidents.
  This is not rocket science, and this will not cost a fortune.  Safety is the New Green, and safety is good for business.

1 Comment
Charlene Blake
7/7/2014 04:21:15 am

Toyota and Lexus vehicles...especially the Toyota Camry...have taken the lead in terms of sudden unintended acceleration-related crashes, particularly storefront crashes. Toyota vehicles have been found to have electronic glitches in the throttle system software (see Michael Barr's finding at embedded gurus dot com) which can result in a full-throttle condition with an ineffective fail-safe. This is a serious state which can lead to fatality or significant injury. A Toyota owner recently won a big court case (Bookout V. Toyota) against Toyota which involved death and injury to the Toyota Camry occupants.

In addition, Dr. Antony Anderson has analyzed the crash of a 2012 Toyota Highlander into a house. He has compared the recordings of the EDR (black box) with the video footage caught in the home security system. Dr. Anderson found discrepancies between the two. He found inaccurate recording of the EDR. This is significant because often the driver of the vehicle which has crashed into a building or storefront is INCRIMINATED based on the EDR alone. The driver is often braking at the time of the SUA initiation, but Toyota claims he/she is not doing so based in the EDR. In some cases prison time has resulted because the EDR results are accepted over the vehicle driver's sworn statement. Toyota owners BEWARE of Toyota's lack of support after an SUA event!

Sudden unintended acceleration is NOT a problem related only to the elderly or women; it is not a driver error problem; it is not a simple stuck accelerator pedal or drifting floor mat issue. This is a DEADLY issue which the automakers, NHTSA, or the Department of Justice (I.e. Toyota's criminal investigation) have not properly addressed. In fact, there is strong DENIAL that the problem exists at all. Yet...the crashes continue at an alarming rate now.

Barriers placed in front of storefronts is a noble gesture. However, this is just a treat-the-symptom maneuver. The CAUSE must be recognized and fully addressed instead of being ignored.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I am an expert in perimeter security and retail and pedestrian safety.  I am also co-founder of the Storefront Safety Council

    CONTACT US

    Archives

    March 2017
    January 2017
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014

    Categories

    All
    2014 Stats
    2014 Storefront Crash Statistics
    ABC NEWS
    ADA Parking
    ADA Spaces
    Addie Hall
    Addison Hall
    AFRA
    ALDI
    Alva Oklahoma
    American Firearms Retailers Association
    Angry Spouse
    Arlington Mass
    ASSE
    ASTM
    ASTM 3016
    ASTM F 3016 Test Standard
    ASTM F-3016 Test Standard
    ASTM Standard
    ATF
    At Risk Day Care
    At-risk Day Care
    Austin
    Bell Ringer
    Bollards
    Bolt Down Bollards
    Burlington New Jersey
    Bystander Dragged
    Cast Iron Decorative Bollards
    CCTV Video
    Cell Phone Stores
    Chicago Crash And Grab Gangs
    City Ordinance
    Comfort Inn
    Costco Bollards
    Costco Crash
    Crash And Grab
    Crashes Into Apartments
    Crashes Into Homes
    Crash Into Costco
    Crash Into Day Care
    Crash Statistics
    CVS
    CVS Storefront Crash
    Day Care
    Decorative Bollards
    Decorative Fencing
    Deliberate Attack On DMV
    Deliberate Crash Into Lobby
    Deliberate Vehicle Attack
    Deposition
    Donna Wine
    Dragged Under Truck
    Drive Aisle
    Driving While High
    Drugged Driving
    DUI
    Dunkin Donuts
    Elderly Drivers
    Elderly Drivers In Florida
    Expert Witness
    Farmers Market
    Farrel's
    Fatal
    Fatal Crash
    Fatal Farmers Market Crash
    Fatalidades
    Fifty Daycare Crashes
    Finkelstein Memorial Library
    Florida Drivers
    Florida Storefront Crashes
    Florist Shop Crash
    Foreseeability
    Fred's Place Crash
    Gas Pump
    Gas Station
    Goal Post Bollards
    Goleta
    Gun Shops
    Hang Up The Keys
    Hathorne NJ
    Impaired Driver
    Impaired Driving
    Jessica Bunch
    Keeping Us Safe
    KinderCare
    Kindercare Crash
    Lack Of Steel Barriers
    Laundromat
    Lexus
    Library Crash
    Matt Gurwell
    Maui Marathon
    Meten A Negocios
    National Preparedness Month
    National Shooting Sports Foundation
    #NatlPrep
    NBC News Crash And Grab
    New Orleans Convention Center
    NOLA Video
    Nose In Parking
    Nose-in Parking
    NSSF
    NTSB
    Orange County Florida
    OSU
    OSU Homecoming
    Otto Drozd
    Out Of Control
    Parklet
    Parklet Crash In Los Angeles
    Pedal Error
    Pedestrian Safety
    Personas Heridas
    Perth Australia
    Preparedness Month
    Prescription Drugs
    Preventable Accident
    Prevention Through Design
    Ram Raid
    Redbox On Notice
    Risk Management
    Rite Aid
    Rocklin California
    Roll-up Doors
    Safety
    Safety Barriers
    Salvation Army
    Salvation Army Volunteer
    Santa Monica Farmers Market
    Sausalito
    Self Serve Laundry
    Senior Drivers
    SERVPRO
    Shameless Promotion
    Sharla Cummings
    ShopRite
    Sidewalk Dining
    Silver Tsunami
    Slide Show
    Soft Target
    South Florida
    Starbucks
    Statistics
    Storefront Crash
    Storefront Crash Stats
    Storefront Safety Council
    Street Closures
    Sudden Acceleration
    SXSW
    Telemundo
    Thank You SERVPRO
    THC
    The Atlantic Cities
    The Gun Vault
    The-playhouse-crash-university-village
    Toyota Camry
    Trader Joe's
    Tti
    Untested-bollards
    Utah
    Vehicle Error Versus Driver Error
    Vehicle Incursion
    Venice Beach
    Verizon Crash
    Walgreens
    Walgreens On Notice
    Westbrook Maine
    Wheel Stops
    Wrong Gear

    RSS Feed

Contact Us
Copyright 2019 by Rob Reiter.  All rights reserved. Content may be freely copied and distributed subject to inclusion of this copyright notice and our World Wide Web URL http://www.storefrontcrashexpert.com.